Ask Rene:
Home Alone…. How Young Is Too Young? 

Hi Rene:

I have two young daughters, seven and eight-years-old and they are with their dad half of the time. I found out from my eight-year-old that they will be alone for 30 minutes to an hour each day they are with him because, after two years, he finally got the motivation to go get a job. ANYWAY…. there is no law in my state about the age of children being home by themselves; it is a case-by-case basis.

I want to get them a cell phone that is just for kids, like the Firefly. He has no home phone so there is no way to contact anyone if they have an emergency. That and I want to make sure they are able to call me when they get home from school and at night since he won’t let them use his phone. What is your opinion about kids their age having a phone of their own?  And, of course, what is your opinion about kids this age staying alone?

Worried Mom


Hi Worried Mom:

I think your signature is appropriate because, to be honest, I’d be a little worried too, if I were you. But it’s a common question and one we’ve dealt with before here on Good Enough Mother. Okay, so let’s break this down; here are the factors I would consider and then the action I would take if I were you. 


Creative Commons/Lyn Lomasi

The fact that the laws are different in different states certainly tends to complicate matters a bit (you can go here to see the numbers of states where there is no specified legal limit. Among those that do, none of them recommend under age eight). I suspect it’s because children mature at different levels and I believe that is truly the crux of the matter here. If the kids are left home alone, you want to know that they could handle themselves in the event of an emergency. Even though it’s only 30 minutes to an hour each day, seven and eight-years-old seems a little on the young side for that. They could be mature for their age but you (and your ex) are the people to best judge whether they are capable of handling unexpected situations.

Read more:  The GEM Debate: Teachers Texting Teens: Too Much?


Creative Commons/mweav31

If you do decide they can stay on their own for that time, you need a safety plan in place. That’s just a good idea, no matter what age the kids . A safety plan would include making sure they have a neighbor they could call on if they run into some trouble. But I am  more than a little worried that your ex doesn’t have a home phone; are your girls responsible enough to know where to find their cell phones  in an emergency?

Read more: Smart Phones And Kids: A luxury Or A Necessity?


Creative Commons/P Shanks

Have either you or our ex-husband talked to the girls about how they feel about this? If so, what did they say? If not, why not? Sometimes I think we as adults get so caught up in making decisions that we don’t take into account the people who are most intimately impacted. Yes, the final decision will be yours to make but I do think they need to be asked. And they need to know that you will listen, even if they can’t affect the outcome.

Read more: Our Story Begins: A Very Particular Set Of Skills…


Creative Commons/kiwanja

To be honest, this is the part of your letter that is most troubling to me. Why are you learning of this rather serious situation from your eight-year-old? Why didn’t your ex-husband mention it to you? Given that (and your above reference to him finally getting a job) it sounds like there’s poor communication between the two of you. I understand the hurt and pain in situations like this but that MUST be put aside for the safety of your children. So a bit of tough love here: everyone needs to grow up so your kids can so the same. Safely.

Read more: Ask Rene: I Want My Ex Back (But He’s Dating Another Girl!)


I wish you the best of luck, mom. I know you can do this!

Do you have a question for Rene? She has an answer. Click here and fire away! And don’t forget to follow the conversation on Facebook and Rene on Twitter.

More from GEM:

Our Story Begins: The Weight Of Words

Ask Rene: I’m Sick Of Being Walked On!

Breaking The Adult Rules: Lessons I Learned From A Trip With My Son